Chowder's Greenblatt on the industry

CH Greenblatt, creator of Chowder (is that his real name?), sent a letter to ANN’s Answerman about his previous column discussing some differences in the animation industries in the US and Japan. The letter has some interesting insights.

I think you’ve actually oversimplified the problem in blaming it all on the executives.… Chowder was an extremely hard sell to the network. They thought it looked too young. They didn’t like the use of patterns. They didn’t like the stop motion.… Very few shows are actually dictated by the executives. They tend to kill good things more often than make them happen. It’s a lot easier to say “No” than “Yes.”…

We do a lot of things well that the Japanese don’t do. They don’t do cartoony. A lot of their storytelling is vague, incoherent, and pretends to be deep (which is probably why it plays well with teens. Ahh, youth.) Each side has its strengths.

Um, but the Japanese DO do cartoony. It just doesn’t get imported that often. The comment about anime that pretends to be deep is spot-on, though.

Also, Chowder is a pretty fun show, though not compelling enough that I want to watch it whenever I see it on.

Jeebus Fata, talk about taking the words out of my mouth. Point for point that is pretty much what I was going to say. I’m going to have to go read that article, though, so thanks for bringing it to my attention, AB.

Fata Morgana:
Um, but the Japanese DO do cartoony. It just doesn’t get imported that often.

What examples could you name?

Crayon Shin Chan and Sugoi-yo Masaru-san come to mind. Heck, Totoro is pretty damn cartoony if it comes down to it. But I suppose it depends on what you mean by ‘cartoony.’

Well, by “cartoony,” I guess I would mean “like Chowder” in this case. I haven’t seen the latter show, and only the domesticated version of the former, so I can’t say anything about them.

I’ve been watching Ramen Fighter Miki over on ANN’s video service, which is quite funny and heavy on physical comedy and impractical situations; I guess it could be considered cartoony.

Syndicate content